The transition from death's-head to cherub motifs on New England gravestones in the late 17th and early 18th centuries reflects a profound shift in colonial attitudes toward death and the afterlife, rooted in the evolving theology of Puritan communities. Initially, from the 1650s to the 1680s, gravestones featured stark death's-head designs—skulls with wings or crossed bones—symbolizing mortality, judgment, and the inevitability of death, consistent with the strict Calvinist beliefs of early settlers. These carvings, often executed by anonymous stonecutters using local slate, were simple and grim, with inscriptions like "Memento Mori" (remember you must die) reinforcing a focus on earthly sinfulness.

This style dominated in coastal areas like Boston and Plymouth, where the earliest gravestone traditions took root.The shift toward cherub or soul effigy motifs began in the 1690s, pioneered by carvers such as John Hartshorne in Rowley, Massachusetts, and later in Connecticut. These designs replaced the death's-head with a stylized angelic face, often with wings, curly hair, and a downturned mouth, symbolizing the soul’s resurrection and hope for salvation. This change mirrored a gradual softening of Puritan doctrine, influenced by the Great Awakening and a growing emphasis on personal faith and divine mercy, which encouraged a more optimistic view of the afterlife. Hartshorne and other early innovators, like the Lamson family in Charlestown, Massachusetts, introduced these motifs as a way to balance mortality with the promise of heaven, marking a cultural pivot that spread from urban centers to rural areas.By the 1720s, the cherub style had gained traction, with carvers like Obadiah Wheeler in Connecticut refining the motif into a regional standard.

The transition was not abrupt but evolved over decades, with hybrid designs—skulls with budding wings or cherubic faces with skeletal hints—appearing as artisans bridged old and new traditions. This period saw increased demand for gravestones as population growth and economic stability allowed more families to commission markers, often reflecting their social status. The cherub’s widespread adoption by mid-century, as seen in cemeteries across Massachusetts, Connecticut, and Rhode Island, underscored a collective shift toward commemorating the deceased with dignity and hope, a stark contrast to the earlier focus on death’s terror.The complete dominance of cherubs by the 1750s, alongside motifs like willow-and-urn designs in the late 18th century, marked the end of the death's-head era, though regional variations persisted. This evolution was driven by both artistic innovation and theological change, with carvers adapting to community preferences and available materials like slate and sandstone. The transition also paralleled broader colonial identity formation, as New Englanders moved from a survivalist mindset to one of established settlement and faith. Today, these gravestones, studied by historians like James A. Slater, serve as a visual record of this cultural transformation, preserved in cemeteries as enduring testaments to a changing worldview
.

1.3”H x 2.3”W